No door policy, no cover, no bottle service. While the summer crowd queues for the scene, these are the year-round taverns and dive bars where Hamptons locals actually drink.
The full ranking
No door policy, no cover, no bottle service. While the summer crowd queues for the scene, these are the year-round taverns and dive bars where Hamptons locals actually drink.
Springs Tavern (Springs)
A storied Springs tavern that was a daily haunt of Jackson Pollock, Willem de Kooning, and Lee Krasner in the 1940s and 1950s, with a casual back patio and a menu of Baja fish tacos and bar classics. No reservations, live music, and a curated cocktail list keep the vibe genuine.
The Montauket (Montauk)
A laid-back Montauk bar with a wide deck and harbor views, drawing a mix of surfers, fishermen, and year-rounders who prefer a cold beer at sunset to a velvet-rope scene. One of the most consistently unpretentious spots on the East End.
Murf's BackStreet Tavern (Sag Harbor)
Sag Harbor's oldest continuously running bar, with roots going back to 1976 in a building possibly built from 18th-century whaling ship timbers. The legendary hook-on-ring game, a packed back patio, and a democratic door policy where hospitality workers and locals have always mixed freely.
Buckley's Inn Between (Hampton Bays)
A Hampton Bays neighborhood roadhouse with a pool table, darts, and draft beer at prices that have nothing to do with the Hamptons season. A genuine year-round locals bar that predates the summer crowd by decades.
Stephen Talkhouse (Amagansett)
Amagansett's legendary live music venue and bar, open since 1970, that has hosted Paul McCartney, The Rolling Stones, Billy Joel, and Van Morrison in its three intimate rooms. The front room pulses with live music; the Tiki Bar spills outside under the stars.
Shagwong Tavern (Montauk)
One of Montauk's oldest taverns, a dark-wood, neon-lit bar with a horseshoe counter, cheap drinks, and a crowd that skews heavily toward year-round fishermen and tradespeople. The antithesis of summer-scene Montauk.
Rowdy Hall (Amagansett)
A lively Amagansett bistro and bar with a French-pub sensibility, known for its moules frites, craft beer selection, and a room that manages to feel both casual and convivial. Popular with the local farming and arts community as much as the summer crowd.
The Dock (Montauk)
A waterside Montauk bar at the fishing docks where the clientele ranges from commercial fishermen to day-trippers, united by cold drinks and a view of the harbor. Straightforward, unpretentious, and exactly what a dock bar should be.
The Blue Parrot (East Hampton)
An East Hampton dive that has been a locals-first anchor for decades, offering cheap drinks, bar food, and a reliably low-key crowd in a village that has otherwise gone almost entirely upmarket.
North Sea Tavern (North Sea)
A Southampton road-trip tavern in the tucked-away North Sea hamlet, with live music, karaoke, bingo, raw seafood, and rotating daily specials. A year-round neighborhood bar that operates entirely outside the Hamptons summer-scene economy.
Ranked across 6 sources: Yelp · Ranked by Rating (May 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (May 2026); Dan's Papers · 8 Hamptons Bars & Pubs 2023 (unordered roundup); Hamptons.com · Best Bars 2025 (unordered roundup); Lords Lane · Best Hamptons Bars 2024 (unordered roundup); Time Out NY · Best Montauk Bars 2024 (unordered roundup). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.