From the legendary basements of MacDougal Street to scrappy Brooklyn rooms, New York is the proving ground of American stand-up. These are the clubs where the next great comic, and a few famous drop-ins, take the mic.
The full ranking
From the legendary basements of MacDougal Street to scrappy Brooklyn rooms, New York is the proving ground of American stand-up. These are the clubs where the next great comic, and a few famous drop-ins, take the mic.
Comedy Cellar (Greenwich Village)
The mecca of American stand-up since 1982, this cramped MacDougal Street basement still draws unannounced drop-ins from the biggest names in comedy on any given night. A strict no-phone policy keeps the room locked in on the jokes.
Gotham Comedy Club (Chelsea)
Chris Mazzilli's elegant Chelsea showroom pairs a polished, table-service night out with consistently strong headliner lineups. Regulars like Jim Gaffigan and Tom Papa keep coming back long after hitting the big time.
The Stand (Union Square)
A bi-level restaurant and comedy club where you can eat Northern Italian fare and high-end cocktails upstairs, then catch acts like Pete Davidson and Adam Sandler drop in downstairs. Named the city's best comedy venue by New York Magazine.
The Tiny Cupboard (Bushwick)
Born as a pandemic-era rooftop hang, this scrappy Bushwick room is now one of Brooklyn's most beloved indie comedy spaces. BYOB energy, folding chairs, and unpredictable lineups make it a favorite of alt-comedy diehards.
West Side Comedy Club (Upper West Side)
Tucked into the basement of Playa Betty's, this cozy, well-run room draws a local crowd and surprise headliners like Bill Burr and Ronnie Chieng. Grab tacos and a margarita, then walk twenty feet to the show.
Stand Up NY (Upper West Side)
The Upper West Side's reliable stand-up room since 1986, where Amy Schumer and Aziz Ansari sharpened their sets and big names still slip in. An unpretentious club that keeps the focus squarely on the comedy.
Comic Strip Live (Upper East Side)
The longest-running stand-up showcase club in the city, open since 1975 on the Upper East Side, where Eddie Murphy, Chris Rock, and Jerry Seinfeld all got their start. A long, narrow room that keeps the spotlight on the stage.
The Village Underground (Greenwich Village)
The Comedy Cellar's larger sister room on West 3rd, now running comedy seven nights a week with the same caliber of drop-ins and a strict no-phone policy. When the Cellar sells out, this is where the magic spills over.
New York Comedy Club (East Village)
A classic brick-wall, candlelit showroom now regarded as one of the best clubs in the country, with a downtown East Village room and a Midtown outpost. Quick-paced showcases mixing regulars, fresh voices, and surprise drop-ins.
Eastville Comedy Club (Boerum Hill)
Brooklyn's oldest comedy club, a 120-seat room steps from Barclays Center mixing local talent with visiting headliners. No drink minimums, craft cocktails, and homemade popcorn keep the night easy.
Ranked across 5 sources: Time Out New York 2025; New York Dearest 2025; Secret NYC 2024; Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.