Frosted, filled, and best straight from the toaster. Every Pop-Tarts flavor ranked by the taste tests that take them seriously.
The full ranking
Frosted, filled, and best straight from the toaster. Every Pop-Tarts flavor ranked by the taste tests that take them seriously.
Frosted Raspberry
A dark-horse favorite and the top pick at both Sporked and The Kitchn, with a bright, genuinely tart filling that cuts through the icing where other berry flavors just taste sweet.
Frosted Blueberry
Tastes like sweetened blueberry jam with a tangy edge, topped with rainbow sprinkles and a shattering layer of icing. Warmed, it reads like a real bakery pastry.
Frosted Cherry
A classic, with warm, round cherry-pie filling and a slight tartness on the finish under a pink sheen and red sprinkles.
Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon
The flavor synonymous with Pop-Tarts, pure cinnamon-sugar comfort with mellow molasses notes, a certified classic since the 1960s.
Frosted S’mores
The flavor that most resembles the real thing, with gooey marshmallow, melty chocolate, and a graham-cracker-like pastry. The Kitchn ranked it number two.
Frosted Wild Berry
A muddled blend of strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, and blackberry with balanced sweetness and a fun blue-and-purple glaze, beloved for nostalgia as much as taste.
Frosted Chocolate Fudge
A sleeper hit, with a rich, tacky fudge filling and a proper chocolate-sauce quality, bold without being cloying. Tasting Table ranked it near the top.
Frosted Strawberry
One of the originals and the everyman pick, a mild, sweet jammy filling that toasts up like a simple strawberry pie.
Frosted Cookies & Creme
An Oreo-adjacent chocolate pastry with a cookies-and-cream filling, sweet and recognizable with an unexpected textural boost when warm.
Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae
A nostalgic dessert flavor pairing a chocolate pastry with a vanilla-cream filling and rainbow sprinkles, decadent if a touch sweet.
Ranked across 3 sources: Sporked · 10 Best Pop-Tart Flavors 2025 (by score); Tasting Table · 15 Pop-Tarts Flavors Ranked 2024; The Kitchn · Best Pop-Tarts Flavors Ranked. Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.