The national freezer aisle, ranked: only brands stocked coast to coast at the big grocery chains qualify. Five taste tests and tens of thousands of retail reviews decide which box earns the oven preheat.
The full ranking
The national freezer aisle, ranked: only brands stocked coast to coast at the big grocery chains qualify. Five taste tests and tens of thousands of retail reviews decide which box earns the oven preheat.
California Pizza Kitchen
The restaurant chain's crispy thin crust line is the taste-test overachiever, with smoked gouda cheese blends and a Neapolitan-inspired crust testers single out as the best in the freezer aisle. Walmart buyers back it up at 4.6 stars across thousands of reviews.
DiGiorno
The brand that invented the rising crust in 1995 and still owns the freezer case. Critics knock the doughiness of the original, but the Stuffed Crust and Detroit-style lines keep landing near the top of cheese-pizza taste tests.
Screamin' Sicilian
Palermo's loudmouthed Wisconsin label piles toppings on with abandon, most famously the Holy Pepperoni's wall-to-wall pep coverage. Its 4.7-star Walmart rating is the highest of any national pizza brand.
Rao's
The premium sauce house's frozen line leads with its bright, herb-laden marinara on a brick oven crust. Food Republic crowned its Five Cheese the single best frozen pizza on shelves.
Freschetta
The sleeper hit: a naturally rising crust with no chemical leaveners that testers call what DiGiorno wishes it were. Savory five-cheese blends and a steady 4.6-star retail rating round it out.
Pizza Antica
The Takeout's 2026 taste-test winner: a Bay Area farm-to-freezer pie, fully baked before freezing, with a floppy, leopard-charred Neapolitan crust and a vacuum-sealed pack of spicy pepperoni you arrange yourself.
Amy's
The organic frozen pizza pioneer since 1987, with a hand-stretched crust, slow-simmered tomato sauce, and a certified-organic ingredient list. Amazon buyers praise a flavor that doesn't taste chemical and a crunchy, top-notch crust, though some call the 13-ounce Margherita a small portion for the price.
Red Baron
The 1976 stalwart wins on dependability: spicy pepperoni, a cheap price, and a solid placing in every taste test it enters. Its Classic Crust Pepperoni holds 4.6 stars from over 7,000 Walmart reviewers.
Motor City Pizza Co.
Detroit-style deep dish with buttery, garlic-bread edges that won both Sporked's and Chowhound's overall taste tests outright. The rare frozen pizza critics say genuinely rivals the pizzeria version.
Urban Pie
Artisan-priced pies with gourmet twists like a creamy rosa sauce that blends marinara and Alfredo under pools of provolone. Daily Meal and Chowhound both ranked it among the top three brands in America.
Ranked across 9 sources: The Takeout · Frozen Pepperoni Pizzas Ranked 2026; Daily Meal · Frozen Pepperoni Pizzas Ranked 2025; Sporked · Best Frozen Pizzas, by Spork Rating (updated 2025); Chowhound · Frozen Pizzas Ranked 2024; Food Republic · Frozen Pizzas Ranked 2024; Walmart Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Target Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Amazon Reviews · Ranked by Star Rating (June 2026); Lineup Positioning · Ranked by Single-Box Retail Price (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.