The full ranking
The pinnacle of agave: extra añejos aged for years, allocated annual releases, and the additive-free icons collectors hunt. Ranked across blind tastings, critic scores, and our own house tasting.
Tears of Llorona (Extra Añejo)
A five-year extra añejo blended across sherry, brandy, and scotch casks by maestro Germán González, often called the Pappy Van Winkle of tequila. Always limited and widely ranked number one.
Clase Azul Ultra (Extra Añejo)
An ultra-luxury extra añejo aged five years in a hand-painted platinum-and-silver decanter, made in numbered batches of around 100. The brand's pinnacle.
Fortaleza Winter Blend (Añejo)
An annual allocated release from the gold-standard traditional house, blending barrels for a richer, deeper expression. A collector's drop each year.
El Tesoro Paradiso (Extra Añejo)
A French-oak, Cognac-cask extra añejo created with maison Alain Royer, refined and complex. A long-revered grail of aged tequila.
G4 Extra Añejo (Extra Añejo)
Felipe Camarena's deeply aged additive-free extra añejo, balancing oak against the house's signature bright agave. A purist's trophy.
Tequila Ocho Extra Añejo (Extra Añejo)
A single-estate, vintage-dated extra añejo from the Camarena family, aged yet still agave-forward. Among the most critically ranked aged tequilas.
Herradura Selección Suprema (Extra Añejo)
One of the original extra añejos, aged up to four years in oak, rich with vanilla, cocoa, and spice. A multiple competition winner.
Jose Cuervo Reserva de la Familia (Extra Añejo)
Cuervo's family-reserve extra añejo, drawn from a private cellar and released in collectible art boxes. A surprising critic favorite and serious sipper.
Don Julio Real (Añejo)
Don Julio's flagship luxury añejo, aged three to five years for a honeyed, caramel-laden sip. A long-standing prestige pour.
Gran Patrón Burdeos (Extra Añejo)
Patrón's grail, an añejo redistilled and finished in vintage Bordeaux barrels and presented in a crystal decanter. Patrón at its most refined.
Ranked across 4 sources: Source of Truths · House Ranking (June 2026); Distiller · The Best Extra Añejo Tequilas 2025 (by community rating); Robb Report · The 50 Best Tequilas of the 21st Century 2025; Tasters Club · The 10 Best Extra Añejo Tequila 2026. Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.