Charred, coal-fired, and chewy: New Haven apizza is a category unto itself. From the white-clam pies of Wooster Square to the city’s newer ovens, these are the best.
The full ranking
Charred, coal-fired, and chewy: New Haven apizza is a category unto itself. From the white-clam pies of Wooster Square to the city’s newer ovens, these are the best.
Modern Apizza (East Rock)
The locals' pick and winner of the 2025 statewide reader poll, a 1934 State Street mainstay whose brick-oven pies and Italian Bomb are the choice of New Haveners who skip the Wooster Square lines.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (Wooster Square)
The 1925 Wooster Square original and the most famous apizza in America, home of the white clam pie. Coal-fired, charred, and chewy, it tops nearly every New Haven ranking and defined the style.
Sally's Apizza (Wooster Square)
Founded in 1938 by a Pepe nephew, Sally's is the other half of the Wooster Square rivalry, beloved for its blistered crust and tomato pies. Tasting Table ranked it first in the city.
Zuppardi's Apizza (West Haven)
Just over the line in West Haven, this 1934 family pizzeria makes its own fresh sausage and a fresh-clam pie that many consider the equal of anything in New Haven proper.
Zeneli Pizzeria (Wooster Square)
A newer Wooster Square arrival from a Naples-trained family, recognized by 50 Top Pizza, bringing true Neapolitan technique to the historic apizza block.
Ernie's Pizzeria (Westville)
A Westville neighborhood favorite that consistently lands on New Haven rankings, prized for a charred, no-frills apizza without the Wooster Square wait.
One6Three (East Rock)
An East Rock pizzeria praised for careful, charred pies, a quieter alternative that earns its place on the city's rankings.
BAR (Downtown)
A downtown brewpub turning out thin, mashed-potato-topped apizza alongside house beer, a New Haven institution and a fixture of the city's best-pizza lists.
Da Legna at Nolo (East Rock)
A wood-fired spot on the State Street corridor, ranked by Tasting Table, known for creative pies and a more contemporary take on New Haven pizza.
Est Est Est (Downtown)
A longtime downtown apizza spot near Yale, a reader-poll favorite serving the classic charred New Haven pie to students and locals alike.
Ranked across 6 sources: One Bite by Dave Portnoy · Ranked by Score (June 2026); Tasting Table · New Haven Pizza, Ranked 2023; NBC Connecticut · CT Pizza Trail Reader Poll 2025 (New Haven, ranked); Boston Magazine · New Haven Apizza Guide 2024 (unordered); Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.