The full ranking
Flavor that lasts, a chew that holds up, and breath you can trust. From checkout-line classics to xylitol upstarts, these are the gum brands America reaches for.
Extra
Wrigley's everyday workhorse, sold in soft, pillowy sticks whose spearmint runs sweet and lasts far longer than its price suggests. Buyers call it top-notch and not too sweet, praising hours of flavor and minty fresh breath, with texture opinions split between soft and hard.
Orbit
The gold standard of the modern gum aisle: tidy packaging, an authentically minty bite, and a complex peppermint that chews refreshed past the ten-minute mark. Reviewers find it delicious, dentist-recommended, and a good value, with mixed reports on how long a piece holds together.
Trident
The original sugar-free stick gum, with an herbal, almost anise-tinged mint and a deserved reputation for some of the longest-lasting flavor at the register. Buyers praise the strong, long-lasting flavor and big-box value, noting it keeps breath fresh and even helps with dry mouth.
5 Gum
Mars Wrigley's sleek, metallic-wrapped line built on intense cooling flavors like Peppermint Cobalt that hit hard from the first chew. Reviewers call the mint strong and long-lasting with a soft texture that is handy to keep in the car, though a few report stale packs.
Ice Breakers
Hershey's cube-format gum studded with crunchy flavor crystals that burst cold, a 2000s checkout-line icon that still delivers. Customers like the flavor and in-package freshness and say it holds up in heat, with texture takes split between pleasingly soft and silly putty.
Mentos Gum
The candy maker's Pure Fresh discs come candy-shelled in car-friendly bottles and resealable bags, with a smooth chew and a mellow, lasting mint. Buyers love the strong mint flavor and soft texture that stays premium, and call the big bag a better deal than single containers.
Dentyne
Dentyne Ice built its name on peppery, sinus-clearing mint and a package that promises a 20-minute chew. Customers love the strong, fresh flavor and breath-freshening power, praise how long it stays minty, and find the multi-pack good value for money.
Doublemint
A 1914 Wrigley original whose smooth, sweet mint has anchored the gum aisle for over a century. Reviewers say the flavor is good and lasts, with some chewing it for anxiety relief or to quit smoking, though a few flag the aspartame on the ingredient label.
Juicy Fruit
The 1893 original with that unplaceable, nostalgia-soaked fruit flavor, more candy than breath mint and proud of it. Buyers love the delicious lasting flavor and large bite-sized pieces that stay soft, though some wish the taste stuck around longer.
PUR Gum
The aspartame-free upstart, sweetened entirely with xylitol and beloved by ingredient-label readers, with a satisfying hard-shell crack and a bouncy chew. Customers call it a great clean alternative that is good for teeth, with mixed words on flavor longevity and price.
Ranked across 5 sources: Chowhound · 14 Gum Brands Taste Test (2025); Mashed · Popular Chewing Gums Ranked (2025); Sporked · Sugar-Free Gum Taste Test 2025 (by Sporks score); Chewing Gum Reviews · Top Brands of 2025 (2026); Amazon Reviews · Ranked by Star Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.