Dry-aged tavern burgers in the West Village, smash classics on the Lower East Side, and steakhouse legends in Midtown. New York's best burgers, by consensus.
The full ranking
Dry-aged tavern burgers in the West Village, smash classics on the Lower East Side, and steakhouse legends in Midtown. New York's best burgers, by consensus.
Red Hook Tavern (Red Hook)
Billy Durney's dry-aged cheeseburger with white onion and American cheese on a sesame bun became the city's modern benchmark. A bar burger executed with steakhouse obsession.
4 Charles Prime Rib (West Village)
The basement steakhouse's double-patty Au Cheval descendant, blanketed in cheese with house pickles. Scoring one at the bar remains a New York badge of honor.
Nowon (East Village)
The Korean-American "classic cheeseburger" with kimchi mayo and a double smashed patty that wins citywide blind tastings. Bar-food swagger with real technique.
Rolo's (Ridgewood)
The wood-fired neighborhood restaurant's burger built on house-ground beef, sharp cheddar, and a legendary fry program. Worth the M train ride by itself.
Hamburger America (Soho)
George Motz's living museum of regional American burgers, from the Oklahoma fried-onion to the classic smash. The country's foremost burger scholar cooking his canon.
Sip & Guzzle (West Village)
The cocktail den's Japanese-inflected luxury burger, griddled to a deep crust and dressed with restraint. A bartender's burger that outclasses most kitchens.
Gotham Burger Social Club (Lower East Side)
The pop-up turned storefront whose smashburgers and gold-standard potato buns built an Instagram empire. The line moves fast and the burger justifies it.
Deux Luxe (Nolita)
Wagyu smashburgers with garlic aioli from the team behind Westchester's Café Deux, served from a sleek Broome Street counter. The luxury end of the smash wave.
Minetta Tavern (Greenwich Village)
The Black Label: dry-aged ribeye and short rib ground into the most famous luxury burger in America, served with caramelized onions in a 1937 room. Still the special-occasion answer.
Crane Club (Chelsea)
Tao Group's wood-fired West Chelsea supper club from Michelin-starred chef Melissa Rodriguez, where the dry-aged prime burger with white cheddar and preserved tomato is capped at a dozen a night. Getting one requires booking smart and ordering early.
Ranked across 5 sources: The Infatuation · 20 Best Burgers in NYC (by score) 2026; Time Out New York · 16 Best Burgers 2025; Time Out · World's Best Burgers, NYC entries 2025; Johnny Novo · NYC Burgers Ranked (by rating) 2026; Yelp · Ranked by Rating · 0.5x Weight (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.