The full ranking
Chopped cheese at sunrise, pho-sauced heroes at midnight, samosas from the cabbie favorite on East 1st. Manhattan corner stores set the standard.
Blue Sky Deli (Hajji's) (East Harlem)
The East Harlem corner deli often credited with inventing the chopped cheese, the ground-beef-and-onions hero that deli worker Carlos Soto chopped together on the grill in the '90s. Still the gold-standard version on a soft hero roll.
Sunny & Annie's Deli (East Village)
The 24-hour Alphabet City institution beloved for sandwiches with cult-followed names: the PHO 1 (roast beef, sriracha, avocado in pho bread), the Bernie Sanders, the Mona Lisa. The crammed colorful aisles were the set of Netflix's Russian Doll.
Punjabi Grocery & Deli (East Village)
The cabbie-favorite East 1st Street storefront slinging hot samosas, curries, and aloo tikki sandwiches around the clock for over two decades. Cash only, ATM inside, no seats, no fuss.
Zaragoza Mexican Deli & Grocery (East Village)
The tiny Avenue A storefront that doubles as a Mexican kitchen, serving carnitas tortas, salsa-drenched burritos, and a famed torta de lengua depending on which meats are still out that day. A bodega in front, a restaurant in back.
Sixth Ave Garden Gourmet Deli (Chelsea)
The Chelsea halal bodega six blocks south of the Empire State Building, beloved for a beef-bacon BEC locals swear rivals any pork version, plus a sandwich menu that runs deep. 4.8 stars across more than a thousand Google reviews.
Don Juan Grocery & Deli (Lower East Side)
The Lower East Side Dominican-goods bodega whose foil-wrapped bacon, egg, and cheese, soft eggs and crisp bacon on a roll, is a Forsyth Street rite of passage. The hot food counter runs Dominican specials all day.
Santiago Deli (Hamilton Heights)
The unassuming Manhattanville deli with a handwritten torta menu pinned behind the cold cuts. The carnitas torta, layered with refried black beans and avocado on soft telera, is the order; the weekend specials are the secret.
Spring Street Finest Deli (Hudson Square)
The Hudson Square corner deli locals duck into after a West Side Highway run, known for solid BECs and a sleeper hit: a lemon-grilled chicken sandwich that punches above the usual bodega menu.
York Delicatessen (Upper East Side)
The small York Avenue corner deli on the far Upper East Side, a longtime neighborhood quick-stop for sandwiches, snacks, and beverages between school, the hospital corridor, and the FDR.
UN Gourmet Plaza (Turtle Bay)
The Turtle Bay deli a block from the United Nations, a clean small market where diplomats and 49th Street office workers grab fast deli food, ready-to-go snacks, and a sideline of imported Asian baked goods.
Ranked across 6 sources: The Takeout (Dec 2025); Tasting Table (Oct 2024); Time Out New York (Dec 2020); Secret NYC (Apr 2023); Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.