Nantucket packs an outsized fine-dining scene onto its few square miles, where harbor-front tables and a short summer season turn fresh local seafood into something close to ceremony. The island runs from candlelit prix-fixe rooms like Straight Wharf, Topper's at the Wauwinet and Company of the Cauldron to buzzy oyster bars like Cru and inventive small-plates spots like The Nautilus. Expect day-boat catch, rose by the carafe and reservations that vanish months ahead.
The full ranking
Nantucket packs an outsized fine-dining scene onto its few square miles, where harbor-front tables and a short summer season turn fresh local seafood into something close to ceremony. The island runs from candlelit prix-fixe rooms like Straight Wharf, Topper's at the Wauwinet and Company of the Cauldron to buzzy oyster bars like Cru and inventive small-plates spots like The Nautilus. Expect day-boat catch, rose by the carafe and reservations that vanish months ahead.
The Nautilus (Downtown)
A clubby, dimly lit favorite serving globally-minded seafood small plates izakaya-style, from crab fried rice to whole roast Peking duck. Inventive cocktails and a buzzy room make reservations essential.
Galley Beach (Brant Point)
The island's only fine-dining spot literally on the sand, Galley Beach pairs New American seafood with sunset views over Nantucket Sound. A large cellar and toes-in-the-sand tables make it a special-occasion favorite.
Oran Mor Bistro (Downtown)
Up a flight of stairs in a historic island home, chef Edwin Claflin's intimate bistro turns out a daily-changing contemporary American menu. Earth-toned dining rooms and a serious wine program make it a quiet fine-dining standout.
Straight Wharf (Harbor Square)
A harbor-side institution since 1976, Straight Wharf builds a nightly-changing prix fixe around whatever is freshest from farm and sea. Dock-side outdoor seating and a deep wine list make it a Best of Boston perennial.
Topper's at The Wauwinet (Wauwinet)
The island's most elegant splurge, Topper's sits at the remote Wauwinet resort with water views on two sides and a princely wine cellar. The seasonal prix fixe and a la carte menus lean on dayboat scallops, sweetbreads and truffle.
Proprietors Bar & Table (Downtown)
A chic, sexily lit cocktail-forward restaurant pouring some of the best drinks on the island alongside creative shareable plates. Hamachi crudo, clam dip and bone marrow anchor a menu built for a long, boozy night.
Breeze (Downtown)
The Nantucket Hotel's nautical-chic all-day spot mixes casual vibes with an upscale, seafood-forward menu and Portuguese accents. The clam chowder is often called the island's best, and the back patio draws a celebrity crowd.
Black-Eyed Susan's (Downtown)
A beloved, quirky cash-only spot with an open kitchen, famous for both creative brunches and a globally inflected, frequently changing dinner menu. Expect a line, classics like linguini with clams and a cult following.
Cru (Straight Wharf)
A see-and-be-seen oyster bar perched right on the harbor, Cru pairs a glittering raw bar with casually elegant plates and rose-soaked afternoons. Lobster rolls, crudo and towers of shellfish make it Nantucket's quintessential summer scene.
Lola 41 (Downtown)
A globe-trotting bistro and sushi bar blending Japanese, Mediterranean and New England influences with locally sourced ingredients. Tuna tartare, sushi and gourmet burgers fuel a lively, late-night scene.
Ranked across 5 sources: The Infatuation - The Best Restaurants in Nantucket; Boston Magazine - The Best Restaurants on Nantucket; Yellow Dog Nantucket - 20 Best Restaurants on Nantucket Island; Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.