The full ranking
San Antonio Italian runs from Luca Della Casa's pasta-driven Nonna Osteria to the firehouse-set Battalion and the city's beloved Paesanos dynasty, home of the iconic Shrimp Paesano. White-tablecloth stalwart Aldo's and Jason Dady's museum-set Tre Trattoria anchor a scene the Texas MICHELIN Guide covers but has yet to recognize for Italian. From Southtown to the North Side, these are the city's essential Italian tables.
Aldo's Ristorante (Northwest)
Named No. 13 on the Express-News Top 50, a white-tablecloth institution that followed its loyal clientele to a sleek IH-10 address, handmade pastas, pristine Sicilian-inflected seafood and a cellar that favors Super Tuscans.
Volare (Olmos Park)
One of the oldest family-owned Italian kitchens in the city, serving authentic pastas and wood-oven pies from the historic Olmos Pharmacy building since 1972, an unchanged intimate trattoria with a steal of a lunch menu.
Paesanos Riverwalk (Downtown)
The flagship of San Antonio's most venerable Italian dynasty has anchored the River Walk for decades on the strength of the iconic Shrimp Paesano in a lemon-egg butter sauce. A two-level terrace with unobstructed Riverwalk views.
Battalion (Southtown)
Housed in a restored 1920s firehouse, Battalion reimagines Italian-American classics with handmade pastas and a sharp natural wine list, moody firelight making the vaulted brick room feel airlifted from Brooklyn. Smoked-meat lasagna is a signature.
Tre Trattoria (Midtown)
Chef Jason Dady's jewel inside the San Antonio Museum of Art delivers Tuscan-inflected family-style Italian amid floor-to-ceiling windows over the Museum Reach, pillowy gnocchi, house-cured antipasti and a campanelle bolognese worth returning for.
Aldino at the Vineyard (North Central)
A North Side hidden gem for nearly three decades, tableside service, al dente pastas and a fresh seafood program that changes with the catch, in a softly lit room backed by an extensive Campanian wine list.
Nonna Osteria (Downtown)
Chef Luca Della Casa, a Food Network Star finalist born in northern Italy, channels his grandmother's recipes into silky house-made pastas, a tableside cheese-wheel preparation and weekly burrata. An intimate Fairmount Hotel room of Old World warmth.
Guillermo's (Downtown)
A 30-plus-year downtown institution in an art-filled room, unfussy pasta, hand-tossed pizzas and a patio scene that packs in Sunset Station and McNay regulars alike, earning both lunch crowds and post-concert dinners.
La Focaccia Italian Grill (Southtown)
Family-owned since 1996 by Luigi and Dolores Ciccarelli, the rare neighborhood Italian locals fight to protect, a compact Southern Italian menu, excellent tiramisu and a courtyard patio that defines relaxed Southtown dining.
Piatti (Alamo Heights)
A loyal Alamo Heights following since 1987 for daily hand-rolled pastas, whole-roasted chicken and a bruschetta board, in a warm wood-beamed room with a covered patio, as close to a Cal-Italian trattoria as the city gets.
Ranked across 5 sources: San Antonio Current · Best Italian Restaurant (2025 Best Of, ranked); San Antonio Express-News · Top 50 Restaurants 2025 (Italian entries); San Antonio Current · Best Italian Restaurant (2024 Best Of, ranked); Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.