Atlanta Italian runs from Craig Richards's pasta mastery at Lyla Lila and Bruce Logue's inventive BoccaLupo to Buckhead's five-decade institution La Grotta. Inman Park stalwarts Sotto Sotto and a wave of handmade-pasta rooms, Gigi's, Storico Fresco, A Mano, define a scene the inaugural MICHELIN Guide American South now covers. From Midtown to Decatur, Old Fourth Ward to Buckhead, these are the city's essential Italian tables.
The full ranking
Atlanta Italian runs from Craig Richards's pasta mastery at Lyla Lila and Bruce Logue's inventive BoccaLupo to Buckhead's five-decade institution La Grotta. Inman Park stalwarts Sotto Sotto and a wave of handmade-pasta rooms, Gigi's, Storico Fresco, A Mano, define a scene the inaugural MICHELIN Guide American South now covers. From Midtown to Decatur, Old Fourth Ward to Buckhead, these are the city's essential Italian tables.
BoccaLupo (Inman Park)
Chef Bruce Logue's creative Italian-American kitchen set the city standard for spicy squid-ink spaghetti and runs Atlanta's only rotating Italian tasting menu, where Southern inflections like pasta corto with collards surface alongside tortellini in umami-rich broth. MICHELIN-recommended.
No. 246 (Decatur)
Ford Fry and Drew Belline built this Decatur anchor around locally sourced Italian-American classics in a chic old-world room, where the eggplant parm and spicy vodka rigatoni are both hall-of-famers. Wood-fired pizzas and a patio that fills on warm evenings round it out.
Storico Fresco (Buckhead)
This Buckhead pasta shop and restaurant blends retail-market energy with a full dining room, serving cacio e pepe, lemony cappelletti spinaci and lasagna alla bolognese at a buzzy pace. The casual vibe hides serious pasta craft. MICHELIN-recommended.
Lyla Lila (Midtown)
Chef-owner Craig Richards brings Friuli-inflected pasta mastery to a candlelit Midtown room near the Fox Theatre, where a legendary crispy duck lasagna with cocoa bechamel anchors a natural-leaning wine list. MICHELIN-recommended.
La Grotta (Buckhead)
Atlanta's most venerable Italian institution since 1978, tucked beneath a Buckhead condo complex with romantic brick archways, and voted Atlanta Magazine's Best Italian for years running. Northern Italian housemade pastas and grilled whole fish have stayed remarkably consistent across five decades.
Sotto Sotto (Inman Park)
Since 1999 this Inman Park institution has paired one of the Southeast's largest all-Italian wine lists with flawless Northern Italian cooking, aqua pazza and an oak-roasted veal chop as perennial anchors. The secluded patio remains the best romantic outdoor table in Atlanta.
Gigi's Italian Kitchen (Candler Park)
A tiny, intimate room of red-and-white checkered tablecloths and candlelight that feels like falling into a romance novel. The focused menu is anchored by housemade cavatelli in a creamy vegetable primavera and a silky tiramisu that punches well above its modest setting.
La Tavola Trattoria (Virginia-Highland)
Exposed brick, dark wood and an open exhibition kitchen give this Virginia-Highland trattoria its rustic warmth, while burrata, veal meatballs, rigatoni alla vodka and a bone-in heritage pork chop prove the menu reaches beyond red-sauce comfort.
A Mano (Old Fourth Ward)
A string-lit patio, lively bar and housemade pastas like bucatini in meaty beef ragu make A Mano the neighborhood Italian that Old Fourth Ward residents fight to get into on weeknights. The carbonara with pancetta, spring peas and farm egg draws particular devotion.
Il Premio (Old Fourth Ward)
Inside the Forth Hotel, chef Brandon Chavannes serves bucatini all'amatriciana with salty pork cheek, Japanese wagyu and olive-oil dirty martinis in a grand piano-lounge setting draped in velvet. Atlanta's best corporate-card Italian room, with an 86 percent Italian wine list.
Ranked across 6 sources: The Infatuation · Best Italian Restaurants in Atlanta (2026); Modern Luxury Atlanta · 11 Best Italian Restaurants (2026, unordered); Atlanta Magazine · Best Italian (readers + critics, unordered); MICHELIN Guide American South 2025, Recommended (unordered); Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.