From Cambridge institutions scooping burnt caramel since the 1980s to nitrogen-frozen microcreameries and a Sharon dairy worth the drive, this is where Greater Boston goes for a cone. Ranked across the city's best ice cream guides plus live Yelp and Google ratings.
The full ranking
From Cambridge institutions scooping burnt caramel since the 1980s to nitrogen-frozen microcreameries and a Sharon dairy worth the drive, this is where Greater Boston goes for a cone. Ranked across the city's best ice cream guides plus live Yelp and Google ratings.
Toscanini's (Cambridge)
The New York Times once called it the world's best ice cream, and Gus Rancatore's Cambridge institution has earned the hype since 1981 with rich, inventive scoops like burnt caramel, kulfi, and B3 (brown butter, brown sugar, brownie).
Delini Gelato (West Roxbury)
A jewel-box West Roxbury gelateria turning out silky, authentic Italian gelato in flavors like Sicilian pistachio, tiramisu, and honey lavender, with waffle cones pressed to order. It pulls near-perfect ratings on both Yelp and Google.
Christina's Homemade Ice Cream (Inman Square, Cambridge)
An Inman Square fixture since 1983, beloved for an ever-rotating board of offbeat flavors, from burnt sugar and fresh ginger to Mexican chocolate and adzuki bean, all made on site.
Crescent Ridge (Sharon)
Farm-to-cone ice cream from a Sharon dairy that has drawn pilgrimages for over 50 years, scooped fast at eight windows. A multi-time Best of Boston winner known for its black raspberry and banana split.
Lazy Bear Creamery (Neponset, Dorchester)
A warm, owner-run Neponset scoop shop with a swing-dotted patio and famously generous portions, pulling some of the highest ratings in the city for flavors like cotton candy, mint Oreo, and its chocolate Lazy Bar.
Honeycomb Creamery (Porter Square, Cambridge)
A from-scratch Cambridge creamery using local dairy for creative seasonal flavors and house-made cones, with standouts like salted caramel crackle, lavender, and chai soft serve.
New City Microcreamery (Central Square, Cambridge)
Liquid-nitrogen, small-batch ice cream frozen to order in Central Square (with a hidden cocktail speakeasy in back), turning out ultra-creamy scoops and one-of-a-kind blends like goat cheese and honey.
The Ice Creamsmith (Lower Mills, Dorchester)
A women-owned Lower Mills parlor making every flavor in house since 1976, cash-only and gloriously old-school, prized for its frozen rum pudding, coconut-almond, and weekly one-off batches.
Forge Baking Co. (Somerville)
A Somerville bakery and ice cream bar serving artisanal scoops alongside its breads and pastries, with house flavors and sundaes built on the same from-scratch ethos.
Far Out Ice Cream (Coolidge Corner, Brookline)
New Zealand style ice cream blended to order, with fresh fruit and mix-ins folded into a soft vanilla or chocolate base, scooped in Coolidge Corner and at Time Out Market Fenway.
Ranked across 5 sources: Time Out Boston · Best Ice Cream, Ranked (2024); Boston Magazine · 30 Best Ice Cream Shops (unordered) 2025; Boston Globe · Best of the Best Ice Cream (unordered) 2026; Yelp · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.