The full ranking
Restored convents and noble mansions inside the walled city. Cartagena's best hotels are 400 years old and brand new at once.
Sofitel Legend Santa Clara (San Diego)
A 17th-century convent in San Diego square turned Accor's Legend flagship, with a Michelin Key and nine straight years on Conde Nast Traveler's top 20 in South America. The walled city's defining hotel.
Casa San Agustin (Old City)
Three whitewashed colonial houses joined by an ancient aqueduct, a Leading Hotels of the World member with a Michelin Key. The most polished boutique stay in the old town.
Casa Pestagua (Old City)
An 18th-century noble mansion restored into a Relais & Chateaux jewel, the only two-Michelin-Key hotel in Colombia. Eleven rooms around the most beautiful courtyard in Cartagena.
Hotel Quadrifolio (Old City)
Eight suites in a colonial manor on Calle del Cuartel with a Michelin Key. Quiet, plant-filled, and fiercely loved by guests.
Hotel Charleston Santa Teresa (Old City)
A former convent on Plaza Santa Teresa with a rooftop pool overlooking the ramparts and the Caribbean. The grande dame of the walled city.
Casona del Colegio (Old City)
A 13-room Michelin-Key boutique in a restored colonial school building, design-forward and intimate. Interiors fold contemporary art into the colonial stone bones, with a courtyard calm the walled city rarely allows.
Movich Hotel Cartagena de Indias (Old City)
A colonial block near Parque Bolivar crowned by the old town's best rooftop pool and bar. The sunset spot even non-guests covet.
Hotel Capellan de Getsemani
A newer boutique on Calle Media Luna in Getsemani with a rooftop pool and spa. The luxury foothold in the city's liveliest quarter.
Bastion Luxury Hotel (Old City)
A restored colonial house near the cathedral with an infinity plunge pool on the roof. Solid old-town luxury at gentler rates.
Ananda Hotel Boutique (Old City)
Twenty-three suites in a 17th-century casona with a rooftop Jacuzzi and one of the old town's better hotel restaurants. A dependable boutique classic.
Ranked across 5 sources: Michelin Guide Keys Colombia 2025 (by key tier); Cartagena Explorer · Best Luxury Hotels in Cartagena (Jul 2025); Conde Nast Traveler Readers' Choice 2025 · Top 20 South America (via press, unordered partial); Google Reviews · Ranked by Rating (June 2026); Live Pricing · 5–6 Months Out (November 2026). Full scoring is on the Methodology tab above.
Related lists
Browse every Top 10 List, see the experts and aggregators behind them, or play the day’s puzzles.